Skip To Main Content

Your Cart

Loading
All Recipes

Mushroom Philly with Black Magic Cheese Sauce

  • Difficulty Moderate
  • Time 3 hours
Mushroom Philly sandwich sliced in half

We have all come to know and love traditional Philly Cheesesteaks at the fair, but they are traditionally made with tender ribeye steak. Chef Aaron Fish changed it up on this classic sandwich letting portobello mushrooms be the star. In this recipe, mushrooms are seasoned with Gnome on the Range, smoked, pulled and then fried for a crispy crunch. Topped with a homemade Black Magic cheese sauce, charred bell peppers, and fresh sprouts to make an elevated sandwich.

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
Mushroom Philly sandwich sliced in half

Mushroom Philly with Black Magic Cheese Sauce

  • Author: Aaron Fish | Fish Food
  • Prep Time: 15 minutes
  • Cook Time: 3 hours
  • Total Time: 3 hours, 15 minutes
  • Yield: 4 servings 1x

Ingredients

Scale

Black Magic Cheese Sauce

Sandwich

  • bread roll, toasted
  • bell peppers, charred and sliced
  • fresh sprouts

Instructions

  1. Toss mushrooms with oil and Gnome on the Range blend.
  2. Place the mushrooms in the smoker and cook for 2 hours at 200 degrees. Remove and shred with 2 forks (like pulled pork).
  3. Toss with rice flour and deep fry at 350 degrees for 2-4 minutes or until crispy. Remove from oil. 
  4. Place on a hoagie with grilled bell pepper, onion, Black Magic Cheese Sauce, lemon zest and Pea Shoots (arugula works too!)
  5. Eat it. Eat it all.

Black Magic Cheese Sauce

  1. Heat milk in saucepan over medium heat until temp reaches 155°F.
  2. Slowly add cheddar cheese one handful at a time while whisking. Don’t let the milk mixture go over 155 degrees.
  3. Add cream cheese and remaining ingredients. Mix well. Reserve for delicious sandwiches or nachos. Maybe just eat it with a spoon because it is that good?
MUSHROOM PHILLY w/ BLACK MAGIC CHEESE SAUCE // FISH FOOD

Used in this Recipe

Other Recipes you might enjoy

Turmeric Smoothie

30+ Tried & True Turmeric Recipes (including a delicious Turmeric Smoothie)

4th of July Hot Dogs

4th of July Hot Dogs

Achiote Bloody Mary Cocktail

Achiote Bloody Mary Cocktail

Achiote Roasted Carrots

Achiote Roasted Carrots