Skip To Main Content

Your Cart

All Recipes

New York Steak – 3 Ways

  • Difficulty Easy
  • Time 30 minutes

Summer grilling equals lots and lots of steaks at Spiceology HQ.  This recipe for New York Steaks 3 Ways will be a hit at your next backyard barbecue. Making compound butter is one of the easiest ways to make something ordinary into something extraordinary. It’s so simple to make, you’ll question why you hadn’t tried it sooner.

Epic New York Steak 3 ways!

It only takes a couple of ingredients to make flavored butter – plus a quick stint in the freezer to make it all solid again – and you’re in buttery delicious business.  Use these flavored butters on pork, chicken, grilled corn, veggies or anything that needs a little deliciousness upgrade.

Grilled New York Steaks Recipes - 3 Ways | Spiceology

Grilled New York Steak Recipe

Makes 4 servings


  • 4 New York Steaks
  • 1 tablespoon DIY Steak Seasoning
  • 4 tablespoons Infused Butter (see below)

Infused Butters

Black & Bleu Butter

Cowboy Crust Butter

Chile Margarita Butter

Instructions for Butters:

  1. In a bowl add the stick of butter and spice rub of choice.  Mix well.  Place on parchment paper and seal well.  Freeze to firm.  Repeat with the other 2 butters.

Steak Instructions: 

  1. Heat your grill to medium-high. Season steaks well with DIY Steak Seasoning. Grill to your liking. In the last minute or so, top each steak with a tablespoon of one of the infused butters and serve immediately.

Show us your creations by tagging #spiceology and #wabeeflove!

Disclaimer: this is a paid collaboration between Spiceology and All opinions are our own.

Used in this Recipe

Top Seller

Other Recipes you might enjoy

Top 10 spices to keep in your kitchen

10 Spices to Keep In Your Kitchen

Turmeric Smoothie

30+ Tried & True Turmeric Recipes (including a delicious Turmeric Smoothie)

4th of July Hot Dogs

4th of July Hot Dogs

Achiote Bloody Mary Cocktail

Achiote Bloody Mary Cocktail

Achiote Roasted Carrots

Achiote Roasted Carrots

Acorn Squash Au Gratin

Acorn Squash Au Gratin

Tinga chicken tacos

Adam McKenzie’s Tinga Chicken Tacos


Adobo Honey Braised Pork

Adobo Honey Pork Tacos

Adobo Honey Pork Tacos

Agedashi tofu in a bowl with broth

Agedashi Tofu

Apple Cinnamon banana muffins drizzled with chocolate syrup

Apple Cinnamon Banana Muffins

Apple cinnamon pork brine

Apple Cinnamon Brined Pork